top of page

What Reasonable Steps to Encourage Contact Really Means.

1d
10 min read

“I can’t force them to go.”


Blonde little girl in a yellow dress covers her face on a leaf-strewn gravel road, with blurred trees and warm sunlight behind.

It is one of the most common things said when a child starts resisting time with a parent. Sometimes it is said with genuine distress. Sometimes it is said because a parent feels stuck. Sometimes it becomes a way of ending the discussion without looking too closely at what is happening around the refusal.


There is a real difference between not physically forcing a child and doing little or nothing to support a safe parent-child relationship.


No child should be dragged, threatened, shamed or punished into seeing a parent. That is not child-focused. But where the other parent is safe, and there is no immediate welfare risk, the relationship should not be allowed to fade simply because the child has expressed reluctance. Children can struggle with transitions, divided loyalties, anxiety, routines and pressure. Those feelings matter. They also need careful adult support.


This article explains what genuinely encouraging contact with a safe parent can look like and why “I can’t force them” should not automatically end the conversation.


If you're an alienated parent or family member and need help with your situation then you should join PAPA today.


At PAPA we have several free to use support spaces, as well as several additional resources available to our Plus members, such as courses, PAPA AI, 1-2-1 help and workshops on family law and mental health.


Eye-level view of a child holding a small backpack beside a garden gate
A hesitant child may need calm support, not pressure or avoidance.

A child’s refusal is a signal that needs attention.


When a child says, “I don’t want to go,” adults often hear it as a final decision. It may be nothing of the sort.


A refusal can mean many different things:


  • The child feels anxious about the handover.

  • They worry one parent will be upset if they enjoy themselves.

  • They are angry about a recent disagreement.

  • They have settled into a new routine and do not want disruption.

  • They feel responsible for managing adult emotions.

  • They have heard negative comments about the other parent.

  • They are nervous after a long gap in seeing that parent.

  • They are genuinely frightened or unsafe.


Those possibilities are very different. They call for very different responses.


A child who is anxious about a doorway handover may need reassurance and a calmer routine. A child who has had a row with a parent may need help repairing the relationship. A child who is being placed under emotional pressure may need the adults around them to stop making them choose. A child who is unsafe needs protection and proper assessment.


That is why “they refused” is rarely the full answer. The more useful question is, what did the adults do next?


The law in England and Wales recognises that, where it is safe, a child’s involvement with both parents is generally important. That does not mean every arrangement must look the same. It does mean that a safe relationship should not be treated as optional simply because the child is finding it hard.


“I can’t force them” is not the end of the question.


There are many things a parent cannot and should not do. A parent should not physically force a child into a car. They should not threaten withdrawal of love. They should not tell the child they are bad, selfish or cruel. They should not create a scene that leaves the child distressed and ashamed.


But reasonable encouragement sits in the space between force and passivity.


If a child says they do not want to go, a child-focused response might sound like:


  • “What are you worried about?”

  • “Has something happened that makes you feel this way?”

  • “Would it help if we texted ahead?”

  • “Would you feel better if the handover was shorter?”

  • “You are allowed to have a nice time with them.”

  • “I know transitions can feel hard, but the adults will help you.”


That kind of response does not silence the child. It listens. It also keeps the adults in their proper role.


Children should be heard, but they should not be made responsible for deciding whether a safe family relationship continues. That is too much weight for a child to carry, especially when they may already feel torn.


In family court, disputes about children often involve close attention to behaviour over time. In family law, the issue is not only what the child said on one difficult day. The court may also look at whether contact was supported, whether practical solutions were tried and whether either household contributed to the breakdown. In some cases, allegations of parental alienation may arise where one parent says the child’s resistance has been encouraged or reinforced by the other.


The label matters less than the pattern. Did the adults try to help the child manage the relationship safely, or did they allow the relationship to collapse without proper effort?


Encouragement is shown through behaviour.


Reasonable steps are usually practical. They are often small. They may not look dramatic. Yet they can make a real difference to whether a child feels emotionally free to maintain a relationship with both parents.


Reasonable encouragement might include:


  • Speaking positively or neutrally about the other safe parent.

  • Avoiding criticism, eye-rolling or loaded comments before handover.

  • Preparing the child in advance for time with the other parent.

  • Keeping routines predictable where possible.

  • Reassuring the child that it is okay to enjoy themselves.

  • Helping the child pack what they need.

  • Supporting agreed handovers.

  • Facilitating phone calls, video calls or messages.

  • Avoiding unnecessary activities that clash with agreed time.

  • Not asking the child to make adult decisions about whether they attend.

  • Responding to worries with calm problem-solving.

  • Encouraging repair after arguments or misunderstandings.


The tone matters as much as the task.


A parent might say, “It is up to you, I won’t make you,” in a way that sounds kind. But for a child caught in loyalty conflict, that can feel like an invitation to choose sides. It may also make the child believe that maintaining the relationship would upset the parent they live with.


A more supportive message might be, “I know you feel unsure today. That is okay. Your other parent is expecting you, and it is safe for you to go. I will help you get ready, and we can talk afterwards about how it went.”


That does not remove the child’s feelings. It gives the child containment.


A child should be listened to, but they should not be left carrying sole responsibility for whether a safe parent-child relationship survives.

Encouragement also means avoiding emotional signals that make separation harder. Long, tearful goodbyes can increase anxiety. Repeatedly asking, “Are you sure you’re okay?” may make a child feel they are going into danger even when they are not. Saying, “Call me if you want to come home,” can sound reassuring, but in some situations it keeps the child emotionally anchored to one home and unable to settle.


A calmer message is often better: “Have a good time. I’ll see you later. You’re okay.”


Close-up of a child’s packed overnight bag beside a pair of small shoes in a hallway
Preparation can help a child feel more secure before time with a parent.

Reasonable steps depend on what is driving the resistance.


There is no single script that works for every child. Reasonable steps depend on age, maturity, history, arrangements, distance, communication between parents and the reason the child is resisting.


A young child may need routine and reassurance. They may need visual reminders, familiar objects or a predictable goodbye. A teenager may need a more respectful conversation, but not a transfer of adult responsibility. They may need to know their views matter, while also understanding that relationships deserve effort and repair.


If the problem is handover anxiety, possible steps might include:


  • A neutral location.

  • A shorter goodbye.

  • A trusted adult helping with the transition.

  • Clear timings.

  • Less adult discussion at the door.


If the problem is a long gap in time together, rebuilding may need to be gradual. Shorter time, daytime arrangements, supported communication or a planned activity can help restore confidence.


If the problem is conflict between adults, the answer may be firmer boundaries. Children should not be used as messengers. They should not hear adult disputes about money, court, blame or past relationship issues. They should not be asked to report back on the other household.


If the child is angry with the other parent, the response should not be, “Well, you don’t have to see them then.” Healthy relationships include repair. A child can be helped to express hurt, ask questions and rebuild trust, provided it is safe to do so.


This is where careful, specific thinking matters. “They don’t want to go” tells only the surface story. The adults need to ask what may sit underneath.


Safeguarding changes the whole picture.


Encouraging a relationship is not the same as ignoring risk.


If there are genuine concerns about abuse, neglect, coercive control, substance misuse, unsafe behaviour, threats, emotional harm or immediate danger, those concerns must be taken seriously. Contact should never be encouraged blindly where a child may be unsafe.


In that situation, the right response may involve seeking advice, gathering evidence, raising safeguarding concerns through the proper route, asking for protective measures or requesting assessment. The child’s words, behaviour and presentation may all matter.


The key question changes.


Where the parent is safe, the question may be:


How can the child be supported to maintain or rebuild this relationship?


Where there may be risk, the question becomes:


What assessment or protection is needed before arrangements continue?


Those two questions should not be mixed up. A child who is frightened because of real harm needs protection. A child who is anxious because of loyalty conflict needs support. A child who has been influenced by adult hostility needs relief from that pressure. A child who is testing boundaries needs calm consistency.


The same sentence, “I don’t want to go,” can sit behind all of those situations. That is why context matters.


Courts often look at the pattern around the refusal of contact.


In disputed cases, one missed visit will rarely tell the whole story. What often matters is the wider pattern.


Questions may include:


  • Was the child prepared for the arrangement?

  • Was the other parent spoken about respectfully?

  • Were worries explored?

  • Were practical solutions suggested?

  • Were handovers made easier?

  • Were calls and messages supported?

  • Were missed arrangements followed by efforts to repair?

  • Were alternative dates offered?

  • Was the child placed in the middle?

  • Was resistance immediately accepted and reinforced?


A parent’s actions can matter as much as the child’s words.


For example, there is a difference between:


“The child was very distressed. I tried reassurance, offered a calmer handover, suggested a shorter visit, informed the other parent and proposed a supported way forward.”


And:


“They said no, so that was that.”


The first shows active parenting. The second may raise questions, especially if it happens repeatedly and no safeguarding issue is identified.


Good records can help. Not exaggerated records. Not angry messages. Clear notes of what happened, what was said, what steps were tried and what solutions were offered. If matters later need to be explained, calm evidence is far more useful than long accusations.


Support should reduce pressure, not increase it.


When a child resists seeing a parent, the adults may feel panicked, rejected, blamed or powerless. That emotional intensity can make things worse.


The goal is not to win an argument at the front door. The goal is to create conditions where the child can feel safe enough, and free enough, to have a relationship without carrying adult conflict.


That may mean slowing things down. It may mean asking for help. It may mean changing handover arrangements. It may mean addressing the child’s worries directly. It may mean being firmer about agreed arrangements. It may mean raising safeguarding concerns where they are genuine.


What it should not mean is leaving the child alone with an adult-sized decision.


PAPA Plus provides ongoing one-to-one case support, specialist resources, courses, PAPA AI and practical guidance for supported self-representation.


For more hands-on help with statements, evidence, enforcement or court proceedings, PAPA Assist provides McKenzie Friend support and additional case services.


A child’s voice matters. So does the behaviour of the adults around them. Reasonable steps to encourage a safe relationship are not about pressure, punishment or pretending everything is fine. They are about steady, practical support that gives the child permission to love and be loved by both safe parents.


In need of help or support?


If you are an alienated parent reading this article and feel you are in need of help and support then please make sure to join PAPA today by signing up here on our website.


This will give you access to our community support forum as well as our Resource Centre, which includes downloadable guides and on-demand courses to help through the process of being alienated and regaining contact with your children.


We also have our Facebook support group that you can join here.


Our Facebook support group has several dedicated chat rooms where you can get immediate support.


If you are a member of PAPA you can also send us a message here on the website and we will try to get back to you as soon as possible but please bear in mind, we have hundreds of messages weekly so it may take us a while to get back to you.


We are currently prioritising PAPA Plus members due to high demand.


Regardless of circumstance you are not alone and at PAPA we are here to support you.


Become a PAPA Ambassador


If you like our resources, articles and support networks and agree with what we stand for then why not get involved and help us push PAPA further by joining our Ambassador Program?


We would love for you to join us and help spread awareness for parental alienation and all of the dynamics involved so that we can continue to help parents and children towards a better future.


Our Ambassador Program allows you to grow your involvement with the cause by earning points on your membership.


To earn points we have created rewards for actions such as completing one of our courses, booking a case review, or ordering supply.


We will be adding new rewards and actions to our Ambassador Program as we continue to grow our awareness efforts.


We want our members to feel rewarded for their support as we continue to look for new ways to improve the lives of those impacted by parental alienation.


You can also become a PAPA Plus member, which will give you exclusive access to even more help and resources.


Each PAPA Plus membership makes a huge difference to the cause as it really helps us to improve our services and our awareness campaigns.


Proceeds from memberships and supply allow us to push the cause much further towards raising awareness and improving our services and resources so that we can continue to help more and more parents and children.


Thank you for reading and for your continued support of PAPA and our mission to end parental alienation.

1 Comment


I find this article helpful in explaining the importance of reasonable efforts to maintain parent-child relationships. After reading informative content like this, I enjoy BitLife which is a life simulation game where family relationships and personal choices shape each life story.

Like

Let's Connect

  • TikTok
Donate with PayPal

Donations are completely voluntary. Any amount will be used to maintain our support networks and to improve our services & campaigns.

Thanks for submitting!

Weekly Updates

Thanks for submitting!

© 2022 by People Against Parental Alienation. Created by Simon Cobb.

bottom of page