Why Some Parents Cannot Accept That Their Child Loves the Other Parent.
- PAPA
- 20 hours ago
- 11 min read
A child should never be made to feel guilty for loving both parents.
After separation, this simple truth can become painfully complicated. Some parents struggle to accept that their child still loves, misses, talks about, or wants to spend time with the other parent. What should be natural starts to look like betrayal.
The child is then pushed into an impossible position. They may feel they have to hide their happiness after contact, stop mentioning memories, reject someone they love, or manage the emotions of the parent they live with.
That is too much for any child to carry.
Children do not experience family separation in the same way adults do. They may feel sadness, confusion, loyalty, relief, anger, hope, and love all at once. They can miss one parent while sitting beside the other. They can enjoy a weekend visit without loving the resident parent any less. They can need both parents, even when those parents can no longer be together.
A child’s love is not betrayal. It is attachment. It is identity. It is part of who they are.
This article is a powerful exploration of how unresolved hurt, jealousy and control can make a parent treat a child’s love for the other parent as betrayal.
If you're an alienated parent or family member and need help with your situation then you should join PAPA today.
At PAPA we have several free to use support spaces, as well as several additional resources available to our Plus members, such as courses, PAPA AI, 1-2-1 help and workshops on family law and mental health.
A child’s love should not become a loyalty test.
When adults separate, the emotional landscape can change quickly. A parent who once felt secure may now feel rejected, replaced, humiliated, or powerless. If the separation was painful, those feelings can be intense.
The problem begins when adult hurt is placed onto the child.
A parent may hear, “I had fun with Dad,” and feel wounded. They may see excitement before a visit with Mum and feel abandoned. They may notice the child speaking warmly about the other household and interpret it as criticism of their own.
The child has not done anything wrong. They have simply expressed love.
Yet small reactions can teach powerful lessons. A cold silence. A sharp question. A disappointed look. A sudden withdrawal of affection. A comment such as, “Well, I’m glad you prefer being there,” or, “After everything they’ve done, you still want to see them?”
The child learns quickly. They begin to scan the parent’s mood. They work out which topics are safe. They may stop sharing. They may become careful, edited, and anxious.
Over time, the child may not think, “I am being manipulated.” They may think, “My love hurts people.”
That belief can follow them far beyond childhood.
When hurt turns into control.
Separation can bring grief, anger, jealousy, fear, and rejection. Those feelings are human. They do not make someone a bad parent.
But feelings become harmful when they start controlling the child’s relationships.
This can happen slowly. It may begin with repeated questioning after contact.
“What did they say about me?”
“Who was there?”
“Did you have a better time than you do here?”
“Did they buy you things?”
“Did they ask about my life?”
A parent may criticise the other parent in front of the child. They may make jokes that are not really jokes. They may suggest the other parent does not care, is selfish, is dangerous, or has “stolen” the child’s affection.
Some parents withdraw emotionally when the child shows love for the other parent. The child may return from contact happy, only to be met with distance. They may learn that joy has consequences.
Other parents make the child responsible for their pain.
They might say:
“I was here alone while you were with them.”
“You don’t know what they put me through.”
“If you loved me, you wouldn’t want to go.”
“You’re just like them.”
These words can feel like emotional traps. The child may start trying to prove loyalty by rejecting the other parent, even when that rejection does not reflect their true feelings.
This is one way parental alienation can begin. It is not always loud or obvious. Sometimes it grows through pressure, guilt, fear, and the repeated message that loving the other parent is unsafe.
The need for exclusive loyalty.
Some parents do not only want love from their child. They want exclusive loyalty.
That need can come from deep insecurity. A parent may feel that if the child loves the other parent, there is less love available for them. They may treat affection as a limited resource, as if the child’s heart must be divided into portions.
But children do not love in that way. A child can love two parents differently, fully, and at the same time.
For some adults, that feels threatening. This can be especially true when the separation remains emotionally unresolved. It can also happen when a new partner enters the picture, when one parent feels replaced, or when old arguments are still alive.
The child may then become part of the adult conflict. They are no longer simply a child with their own needs. They become a source of reassurance, proof, validation, or control.
That role is deeply unfair.
A child should not have to soothe a parent’s jealousy. They should not have to prove devotion by withholding affection from someone else. They should not have to act as a witness, spy, counsellor, messenger, or emotional partner.
When a child is placed in that role, the parent-child relationship becomes distorted. The child may feel powerful in one sense, because their words and choices seem to matter so much. But they are also trapped. Their emotional freedom disappears.
How children adapt to emotional pressure.
Children are highly sensitive to the emotional climate around them. They notice tone, facial expression, silence, and tension. Even young children can sense when a subject makes a parent uncomfortable.
When love for the other parent causes conflict, many children adapt by hiding parts of themselves.
They may stop talking about the other home. They may pretend visits were boring. They may say they do not want to go, because that feels safer than admitting they are excited. They may repeat adult phrases they barely understand.
A child might say, “I don’t want to see him because he never cared about us,” or, “She ruined everything.” Sometimes those words reflect real experiences. Sometimes they reflect what the child has heard, absorbed, and learned is acceptable to say.
Children may also develop split behaviour. In one home, they express love freely. In the other, they deny it. This does not mean the child is dishonest in a calculated way. It usually means the child is trying to survive emotionally.
They are asking, often without words, “Who do I have to be so I do not lose your love?”
That question should never sit at the centre of childhood.
The damage reaches the child’s identity.
Children are not possessions, and love is not a competition.
Forcing a child to choose can damage their sense of self because children are connected to both parents. They may share a parent’s face, humour, temperament, culture, family history, or memories. When one parent is constantly attacked, the child may feel that part of themselves is being attacked too.
This can create deep confusion.
If one parent says the other is worthless, selfish, cruel, or unlovable, the child may wonder what that means about them. They may feel guilty for missing that parent. They may feel ashamed of enjoying time with them. They may worry that they are bad for loving someone they have been told to reject.
The emotional impact can show in different ways:
anxiety before and after contact
stomach aches, headaches, or sleep problems
guilt when enjoying time with either parent
fear of saying the wrong thing
sudden anger towards one parent
people-pleasing and emotional caretaking
withdrawal, secrecy, or sadness
difficulty trusting their own feelings
Some children become very compliant. They say what the dominant parent wants to hear. They learn to manage adult moods. They become skilled at avoiding conflict.
Others become angry or defiant. They may reject contact, refuse calls, or speak harshly. Adults may then assume the child has made a clear choice. But beneath the surface, that child may be carrying fear, confusion, and loyalty conflict.
When a child feels pressured by one parent to become alienated from the other, the harm is not limited to one relationship. It can affect the child’s confidence, emotional safety, and belief that love can be steady.
Protection is different from possession.
There are situations where contact with a parent must be restricted. Children must be protected from abuse, neglect, violence, coercive control, substance misuse, or any behaviour that places them at risk.
Safeguarding matters. A child’s safety comes first.
But protection is not the same as possession.
A protective parent focuses on the child’s welfare. They seek appropriate support. They keep records where needed. They follow legal and safeguarding advice. They avoid making the child responsible for adult decisions. They do not use the child as a weapon.
A possessive parent may use the language of protection while acting from anger, revenge, fear, or control. They may block contact to punish the other parent. They may exaggerate ordinary disagreements. They may treat the child’s affection as evidence that the other parent is manipulating them.
The key question should always be:
Is the child being kept safe, or are they being made to carry an adult’s unresolved emotions?
That question does not dismiss genuine risk. It helps separate real safeguarding from emotional ownership.
Anyone facing serious concerns about a child’s safety should seek qualified legal advice and appropriate safeguarding support. This article is for general information and cannot assess individual family circumstances.
What secure parenting looks like after separation.
A secure parent does not need a child to reject someone else in order to feel loved.
Secure parenting after separation does not mean pretending everything is easy. It does not mean liking the other parent. It does not mean ignoring harm or erasing the past.
It means keeping the child out of the emotional crossfire.
A secure parent allows the child to have their own experience. They can tolerate hearing that the child enjoyed time elsewhere. They can respond with warmth when the child says they miss the other parent. They can make room for mixed feelings without taking them personally.
That might sound like:
“I’m glad you had a nice time.”
“It’s okay to miss them.”
“You can love us both.”
“You don’t have to choose.”
“Adult problems are for adults to sort out.”
These sentences may seem simple, but they give a child emotional permission. They tell the child that love is safe. They reduce the pressure to perform loyalty. They help the child stay whole.
Secure parenting also means speaking carefully. Children do not need adult details about betrayal, court proceedings, finances, or blame. They need stability, honesty at an age-appropriate level, and freedom from adult burdens.
A parent can set boundaries without attacking the other parent. They can say, “That arrangement does not work, so the adults will discuss it,” rather than, “They never think about anyone but themselves.”
The difference matters. One protects the child. The other recruits the child.
Why some parents cannot let go of the conflict.
Some parents remain emotionally tied to the separation long after the relationship ends. The conflict becomes part of their identity. They may feel that accepting the child’s love for the other parent means accepting defeat, excusing harm, or losing importance.
They may also fear being forgotten. If the child enjoys the other home, they may feel replaced. If the other parent has a new partner, they may fear the child will form a bond there. If the child looks forward to contact, they may hear it as, “You are not enough.”
These reactions often sit on top of pain. But pain does not give a parent the right to control a child’s heart.
A child cannot heal an adult’s rejection. A child cannot undo the separation. A child cannot provide the emotional security that an adult needs to build for themselves.
When a parent expects this, the child loses the freedom to be a child.
Healing requires adults to seek support from other adults. Friends, family, counsellors, support services, mediators, or legal professionals may all have a role depending on the situation. The child should not be the place where adult pain is deposited.
The child needs permission to love freely.
The healthiest message a separated parent can give is clear:
“You are allowed to love both of us.”
This does not erase boundaries. It does not require forced contact where there is genuine danger. It does not mean every parent has behaved well. It simply recognises that a child’s emotional world belongs to the child.
Children need space to form their own relationships. They need to make sense of each parent without being coached, shamed, or pressured. They need to know that their feelings will not cost them affection.
When children are allowed to love freely, they do not have to split themselves in two. They can talk honestly. They can return from contact without fear. They can ask questions. They can miss one parent while being held by the other.
That freedom is not a gift to the other parent. It is a gift to the child.
Parents may separate, but children should never be forced to divide their heart.
A child’s love is not evidence of disloyalty. It is not a prize to be won. It is not a weapon to use in an adult battle.
Real love gives children permission to love safely, openly, and without guilt. A secure parent can bear the truth that the child has room in their heart for more than one person. That truth does not reduce love. It protects it.
In need of help or support?
If you are an alienated parent reading this article and feel you are in need of help and support then please make sure to join PAPA today by signing up here on our website.
This will give you access to our community support forum as well as our Resource Centre, which includes downloadable guides and on-demand courses to help through the process of being alienated and regaining contact with your children.
We also have our Facebook support group that you can join here.
Our Facebook support group has several dedicated chat rooms where you can get immediate support.
If you are a member of PAPA you can also send us a message here on the website and we will try to get back to you as soon as possible but please bear in mind, we have hundreds of messages weekly so it may take us a while to get back to you.
We are currently prioritising PAPA Plus members due to high demand.
Regardless of circumstance you are not alone and at PAPA we are here to support you.
Become a PAPA Ambassador.
If you like our resources, articles and support networks and agree with what we stand for then why not get involved and help us push PAPA further by joining our Ambassador Program?
We would love for you to join us and help spread awareness for parental alienation and all of the dynamics involved so that we can continue to help parents and children towards a better future.
Our Ambassador Program allows you to grow your involvement with the cause by earning points on your membership.
To earn points we have created rewards for actions such as completing one of our courses, booking a case review, or ordering supply.
We will be adding new rewards and actions to our Ambassador Program as we continue to grow our awareness efforts.
We want our members to feel rewarded for their support as we continue to look for new ways to improve the lives of those impacted by parental alienation.
You can also become a PAPA Plus member, which will give you exclusive access to even more help and resources.
Each PAPA Plus membership makes a huge difference to the cause as it really helps us to improve our services and our awareness campaigns.
Proceeds from memberships and supply allow us to push the cause much further towards raising awareness and improving our services and resources so that we can continue to help more and more parents and children.
Thank you for reading and for your continued support of PAPA and our mission to end parental alienation.
Comments